Stat-Ease Blog

Next in our 40th anniversary “Ask an Expert” blog series is Leonard “Len” Rubinstein, a Distinguished Scientist at Merck. He has over 3 decades of experience in the pharmaceutical industry, with a background in immunology. Len has spent the last couple of decades working on bioanalytical development, supporting bioprocess and clinical assay endpoints. He’s also a decades-long proponent of design of experiments (DOE), so we reached out to learn what he has to say!

When did you first learn about DOE? What convinced you to try it?

I first learned about DOE in 1996. I enrolled in a six-day training course to better understand the benefits of this approach in my assay development.

What convinced you to stick with DOE, rather than going back to one-factor-at-a-time (OFAT) designs?

Once I started using the DOE approach, I was able to shorten development time but, more importantly, gained insights into understanding interactions and modeling the results to predict optimal parameters that provided the most robust and least variable bioanalytical methods. Afterward, I could never go back to OFAT!

How do you currently use & promote DOE at your company?

DOE has been used in many areas across the company for years, but it has not been explicitly used for the analytical methods supporting clinical studies. I raised awareness through presentations and some brief training sessions. Afterward, after my management adopted it, I started sponsoring the training. Since 2018, I have sponsored four in-person training sessions, each with 20 participants.

Some examples of where we used DOE can be found at the end of this interview.

What’s been your approach for spreading the word about how beneficial DOE is?

Convincing others to use DOE is about allowing them to experience the benefits and see how it’s more productive than using an OFAT approach. They get a better understanding of the boundaries of the levels of their factors to have little effect on the result and, more importantly, sometimes discard what they thought was an important factor(s) in favor of those that truly influenced their desired outcome.

Is there anything else you’d like to share to further the cause of DOE?

It would be beneficial if our scientists were exposed to DOE approaches in secondary education, be it a BA/BS, MA/MS, or PhD program. Having an introduction better prepares those who go on to develop the foundation and a desire to continue using the DOE approach and honing their skills with this type of statistical design in their method development.

And there you have it! We appreciate Len’s perspective and hope you’re able to follow in his footsteps for experimental success. If you’re a secondary education teacher and want to take Len’s advice about introducing DOE to your students, send us a note: we have “course-in-a-box” options for qualified instructors, and we offer discounts to all academics who want to use Stat-Ease software or learn DOE from us.

Len’s published research:

Whiteman, M.C., Bogardus, L., Giacone, D.G., Rubinstein, L.J., Antonello, J.M., Sun, D., Daijogo, S. and K.B. Gurney. 2018. Virus reduction neutralization test: A single-cell imaging high-throughput virus neutralization assay for Dengue. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 99(6):1430-1439.

Sun, D., Hsu, A., Bogardus, L., Rubinstein, L.J., Antonello, J.M., Gurney, K.B., Whiteman, M.C. and S. Dellatore. 2021. Development and qualification of a fast, high-throughput and robust imaging-based neutralization assay for respiratory syncytial virus. Journal of Immunological Methods. 494:113054

Marchese, R.D., Puchalski, D., Miller, P., Antonello, J., Hammond, O., Green, T., Rubinstein, L.J., Caulfield, M.J. and D. Sikkema. 2009. Optimization and validation of a multiplex, electrochemiluminescence-based detection assay for the quantitation of immunoglobulin G serotype-specific anti-pneumococcal antibodies in human serum. Clinical and Vaccine Immunology. 16(3):387-396.

Welcome to our first Publication Roundup! In these monthly posts, we'll feature recent papers that cited Design-Expert® or Stat-Ease® 360 software. Please submit your paper to us if you haven't seen it featured yet!

Mark's comment: make sure to check out publication #4 by researchers from GITAM School of Science in Hyderabad, India. They provide all the raw data, the ANOVAs, model graphs and, most importantly, enhancing the quality of medicines via multifactor design of experiments (DOE).

1. Innovative study on chalcopyrite flotation efficiency with xanthate and ester collectors blend using response surface methodology (B.B.D): towards sustainability
   Scientific Reports volume 15, Article number: 65 (2025)
   Authors: Imkong Rathi & Shravan Kumar
   
2. Fabrication and In Vivo Evaluation of In Situ pH-Sensitive Hydrogel of Sonidegib–Invasomes via Intratumoral Delivery for Basal Cell Skin Cancer Management
   Pharmaceuticals 2025, 18(1), 31
   Authors: Maha M. Ghalwash, Amr Gamal Fouad, Nada H. Mohammed, Marwa M. Nagib, Sherif Faysal Abdelfattah Khalil, Amany Belal, Samar F. Miski, Nisreen Khalid Aref Albezrah, Amani Elsayed, Ahmed H. E. Hassan, Eun Joo Roh, & Shaimaa El-Housiny
   
3. Formulation development and evaluation, in silico PBPK modeling and in vivo pharmacodynamic studies of clozapine matrix type transdermal patches
   Scientific Reports volume 15, Article number: 1204 (2025)
   Authors: Abdul Qadir, Syed Umer Jan, Muhammad Harris Shoaib, Muhammad Sikandar, Rabia Ismail Yousuf, Fatima Ramzan Ali, Fahad Siddiqui, Abdul Jabbar Magsi, Ghulam Mustafa, Muhammad Talha Saleem, Shafi Mohammad, Mohammad Younis & Muhammad Arsalan
   
4. Unique Research for Developing a Full Factorial Design Evaluated Liquid Chromatography Technique for Estimating Budesonide and Formoterol Fumarate Dihydrate in the Presence of Specified and Degradation Impurities in Dry Powder Inhalation
   Biomedical Chromatography: Volume 39, Issue 2, February 2025
   Authors: Lova Gani Raju Bandaru, Naresh Konduru, Leela Prasad Kowtharapu, Rambabu Gundla, Phani Raja Kanuparthy, Naresh Kumar Katari
   
5. Synergistic effects of fly ash and graphene oxide composites at high temperatures and prediction using ANN and RSM approach
   Scientific Reports volume 15, Article number: 1604 (2025)
   Authors: I. Ramana & N. Parthasarathi
   
6. Enhancement Strategy for Protocatechuic Acid Production Using Corynebacterium glutamicum with Focus on Continuous Fermentation Scale-Up and Cytotoxicity Management
   International Journal of Molecular Sciences 2025, 26(1), 396
   Authors: Jiwoon Chung, Wooshik Shin, Chulhwan Park, and Jaehoon Cho
   
7. An exploration of RSM, ANN, and ANFIS models for methylene blue dye adsorption using Oryza sativa straw biomass: a comparative approach
   Scientific Reports volume 15, Article number: 2979 (2025)
   Authors: Sheetal Kumari, Smriti Agarwal, Manish Kumar, Pinki Sharma, Ajay Kumar, Abeer Hashem, Nouf H. Alotaibi, Elsayed Fathi Abd-Allah & Manoj Chandra Garg
   
8. Manipulated Slow Release of Florfenicol Hydrogels for Effective Treatment of Anti-Intestinal Bacterial Infections
   International Journal of Nanomedicine, Volume 2025:20, Pages 541—555, 13 January 2025.
   Authors: Luo W, Zhang M, Jiang Y, Ma G, Liu J, Dawood AS, Xie S, Algharib SA
   
9. Preparation of slow-release fertilizer derived from rice husk silica, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, polyvinyl alcohol and paper composite coated urea
   Heliyon, Volume 11, Issue 2, 30 January 2025
   Authors: Idayatu Dere, Daniel T. Gungula, Semiu A. Kareem, Fartisincha Peingurta Andrew, Abdullahi M. Saddiq, Vadlya T. Tame, Haruna M. Kefas, David O. Patrick, Japari I. Joseph
   
10. Elimination of Ni(II) from wastewater using metal-organic frameworks and activated algae encapsulated in chitosan/carboxymethyl cellulose hydrogel beads: Adsorption isotherm, kinetic, and optimizing via Box-Behnken design optimization
    International Journal of Biological Macromolecules, 21 January 2025, In Press, Journal Pre-proof
    Authors: Gamil A.A.M. Al-Hazmi, Nadia H. Elsayed, Jawza Sh. Alnawmasi, Khadra B. Alomari, Ali Hamzah Alessa, Shareefa Ahmed Alshareef, A.A. El-Bindary
    
11. QbD-Driven preparation, characterization, and pharmacokinetic investigation of daidzein-l oaded nano-cargos of hydroxyapatite
    Scientific Reports volume 15, Article number: 2967 (2025)
    Authors: Namrata Gautam, Debopriya Dutta, Saurabh Mittal, Perwez Alam, Nasr A. Emad, Mohamed H. Al-Sabri, Suraj Pal Verma & Sushama Talegaonkar
    
12. Lubricity potentials of Azadirachta indica (neem) oil and Cyperus esculentus (tiger nut) oil extracts and their blends in machining of mild steel material
    Heliyon, Volume 11, Issue 2, 30 January 2025
    Authors: Ignatius Echezona Ekengwu, Ikechukwu Geoffrey Okoli, Obiora Clement Okafor, Obiora Nnaemeka Ezenwa, Joseph Chikodili Ogu
    
13. Process Evaluation and Analysis of Variance of Rice Husk Gasification Using Aspen Plus and Design Expert Software
    Chemistry Africa (2025)
    Authors: Ernest Mbamalu Ezeh, Isah Yakub Mohammed, Epere Aworabhi, Yousif Abdalla

Thank you to our presenters and all the attendees who showed up to our 2022 Online DOE Summit! We're proud to host this annual, premier DOE conference to help connect practitioners of design of experiments and spread best practices & tips throughout the global research community. Nearly 300 scientists from around the world were able to make it to the live sessions, and many more will be able to view the recordings on the Stat-Ease YouTube channel in the coming months.

Due to a scheduling conflict, we had to move Martin Bezener's talk on "The Latest and Greatest in Design-Expert and Stat-Ease 360." This presentation will provide a briefing on the major innovations now available with our advanced software product, Stat-Ease 360, and a bit of what's in store for the future. Attend the whole talk to be entered into a drawing for a free copy of the book DOE Simplified: Practical Tools for Effective Experimentation, 3rd Edition. New date and time: Wednesday, October 12, 2022 at 10 am US Central time.

Even if you registered for the Summit already, you'll need to register for the new time on October 12. Click this link to head to the registration page. If you are not able to attend the live session, go to the Stat-Ease YouTube channel for the recording.

Want to be notified about our upcoming live webinars throughout the year, or about other educational opportunities? Think you'll be ready to speak on your own DOE experiences next year? Sign up for our mailing list! We send emails every month to let you know what's happening at Stat-Ease. If you just want the highlights, sign up for the DOE FAQ Alert to receive a newsletter from Engineering Consultant Mark Anderson every other month.

Thank you again for helping to make the 2022 Online DOE Summit a huge success, and we'll see you again in 2023!